FabSwingers.com > Forums > Politics > Isreal and the Gaza conflict video
Isreal and the Gaza conflict video
Jump to: Newest in thread
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Yes Israel is real... Just saying"  trouble maker!  | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Are you seriously trying to tell me you know more than this orthodox Jew!? Seriously? https://youtu.be/_FNtMV2i8-8?si=tZl7mRX9KYWa0JMS " Haha. Hahahaha. You've just linked the Jewish equivalent of the Raving Monster Looney Party. The ones Diane Abbott referenced, to much ridicule. That guy is from an extreme fringe group. For balance, see Son of Hamas! https://youtu.be/399gQcui04A?si=lDUWlsg2qtdjY5zx https://youtu.be/OyqKTuqzKWs?si=ZUiLxOQKrI55Umwz | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Are you seriously trying to tell me you know more than this orthodox Jew!? Seriously? https://youtu.be/_FNtMV2i8-8?si=tZl7mRX9KYWa0JMS Haha. Hahahaha. You've just linked the Jewish equivalent of the Raving Monster Looney Party. The ones Diane Abbott referenced, to much ridicule. That guy is from an extreme fringe group. For balance, see Son of Hamas! https://youtu.be/399gQcui04A?si=lDUWlsg2qtdjY5zx https://youtu.be/OyqKTuqzKWs?si=ZUiLxOQKrI55Umwz " The examples you have just shows how wrong it all is Is the path of hate and endless warfare seriously your solution? I'd prefer to listen to the more wise people. Have a laugh at this video then.. https://youtu.be/YVmCwhFk6Pc?si=YiO02hSJ7aSx3Ib7 | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I'd prefer to listen to the more wise people. Have a laugh at this video then.. https://youtu.be/YVmCwhFk6Pc?si=YiO02hSJ7aSx3Ib7 " Watched the first three seconds. Some dude unbuttoning a sleeve to show a Holocaust tattoo. When someone begins a video with their Holocaust credentials in such an emotively evocative way, there's something wrong. It's a shortcut to say "you need to trust me because it's who I am, not what I say". It's so that people can say "how could you argue, after all he went through". It's so you can make a gotcha comment, like "have a laugh at this" - who can laugh at a man unrolling their sleeve to show a Holocaust tattoo? How very clever! What he says matters not at all. Here's why: The vast, vast majority of Holocaust survivors support Israel. The Holocaust was not a filter that selected the "wise people", it was indiscriminate. So the fact that you, a rabidly anti-Israel Brit, can cherry pick quotes from the marginal percent of Holocaust survivors who dislike Israel is totally disingenuous. There's an Indian guy on YouTube who argues that British colonialism was a good thing. There's an African guy on YouTube who argues that the blacks in the US have benefited from their ancestors being brought over as sl@ves. There's a Saudi guy who's vociferously pro-Israel. Well done for finding "Jews against Israel". Next, why not find a pro-Putin Ukrainian - there are plenty on YouTube. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"When someone begins a video with their Holocaust credentials in such an emotively evocative way, there's something wrong. It's a shortcut to say "you need to trust me because it's who I am, not what I say". " Yeah, I've seen Gabor Mate do this -- he speaks passionately, but relates more to his own experience in the IDF and mixes it with a bit of incorrect history. He should stick to being a psychologist. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"There's a Saudi guy who's vociferously pro-Israel." If you're talking about Loay Alshareef, I actually think he's very good: https://youtu.be/v3HeiWIjcI0?si=bGCmdYzFQYCoQ1EX I've heard one of his longer interviews too, and it is very positively focused. But, like you say, we need to be careful with emotionally evocative stuff - it's not always factual. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" If you're talking about Loay Alshareef, I actually think he's very good: https://youtu.be/v3HeiWIjcI0?si=bGCmdYzFQYCoQ1EX I've heard one of his longer interviews too, and it is very positively focused. But, like you say, we need to be careful with emotionally evocative stuff - it's not always factual." The only point is that one can always find someone from any group with an unlikely viewpoint for or against something. That doesn't necessarily prove anything, especially when cherry picked. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"The only point is that one can always find someone from any group with an unlikely viewpoint for or against something. That doesn't necessarily prove anything, especially when cherry picked." Many years ago I knew a guy with a black wife and mixed-race daughter - I later found out he voted BNP.
Go figure! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"This is all about Netanyahu's desperate grip to power. Strong parallels with Putin's forays into Ukraine. The man will do anything including ethnic cleansing and war crimes. All eyes on Gaza but events in West Bank tells you a lot about where the conflict is heading. This is about land and territory. " Absolutely this Prime waterfront real estate is not going back to former Palestinian residents . | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Many years ago I knew a guy with a black wife and mixed-race daughter - I later found out he voted BNP.
Go figure! ""Some of my best friends are [insert group here against which I'm now demonstrably not anti]." | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"This is all about Netanyahu's desperate grip to power. Strong parallels with Putin's forays into Ukraine. The man will do anything including ethnic cleansing and war crimes. All eyes on Gaza but events in West Bank tells you a lot about where the conflict is heading. This is about land and territory. Absolutely this Prime waterfront real estate is not going back to former Palestinian residents . " 
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" If you're talking about Loay Alshareef, I actually think he's very good: https://youtu.be/v3HeiWIjcI0?si=bGCmdYzFQYCoQ1EX I've heard one of his longer interviews too, and it is very positively focused. But, like you say, we need to be careful with emotionally evocative stuff - it's not always factual. The only point is that one can always find someone from any group with an unlikely viewpoint for or against something. That doesn't necessarily prove anything, especially when cherry picked." Is this cherry picked? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.timesofisrael.com/labor-chief-michaeli-rabin-was-assassinated-with-netanyahus-cooperation/amp/ | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"This is all about Netanyahu's desperate grip to power. Strong parallels with Putin's forays into Ukraine. The man will do anything including ethnic cleansing and war crimes. All eyes on Gaza but events in West Bank tells you a lot about where the conflict is heading. This is about land and territory. Absolutely this Prime waterfront real estate is not going back to former Palestinian residents .
"After the 6 day War 1967, Israel occupied Gaza and a large chunk of Egypt. They didn't keep it though they handed it back to Egypt. In 2005 Israel left Gaza completely. So why should they want it now, doesn't add up. Oh I know, maybe to stop missile and terrorist attacks against there citizens. Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Is this cherry picked? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.timesofisrael.com/labor-chief-michaeli-rabin-was-assassinated-with-netanyahus-cooperation/amp/ " Um... QED? The fact that you choose an article is sort of the point of... (sigh) What's your point, exactly? That over half of Israel hates Netanyahu, that his rhetoric turns off the left and that Israel has politics, like most other countries? Mind. Blown. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"This is all about Netanyahu's desperate grip to power. Strong parallels with Putin's forays into Ukraine. The man will do anything including ethnic cleansing and war crimes. All eyes on Gaza but events in West Bank tells you a lot about where the conflict is heading. This is about land and territory. Absolutely this Prime waterfront real estate is not going back to former Palestinian residents .
After the 6 day War 1967, Israel occupied Gaza and a large chunk of Egypt. They didn't keep it though they handed it back to Egypt. In 2005 Israel left Gaza completely.
So why should they want it now, doesn't add up. Oh I know, maybe to stop missile and terrorist attacks against there citizens.
Mrs x"The average price of owner-occupied dwellings in Israel rose by 9.34% to ILS1,969,800 (US$531,933) in Q1 2023 from a year earlier, its eleventh consecutive quarter of y-o-y increase.4 Aug 2023 Why is Israeli property so expensive? Limited land availability: Israel is a relatively small country with a limited amount of land available for development. This scarcity of land, particularly in desirable areas, can drive up property prices Bulldozers in, job is half done anyway, no tenants to evict or courts. It’s now Israeli occupied, taken by force and USA supplied bombs for the demolition, USA will probably help with contracts for the rebuilding into new homes for Israelis. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"This is all about Netanyahu's desperate grip to power. Strong parallels with Putin's forays into Ukraine. The man will do anything including ethnic cleansing and war crimes. All eyes on Gaza but events in West Bank tells you a lot about where the conflict is heading. This is about land and territory. Absolutely this Prime waterfront real estate is not going back to former Palestinian residents .
After the 6 day War 1967, Israel occupied Gaza and a large chunk of Egypt. They didn't keep it though they handed it back to Egypt. In 2005 Israel left Gaza completely.
So why should they want it now, doesn't add up. Oh I know, maybe to stop missile and terrorist attacks against there citizens.
Mrs x
The average price of owner-occupied dwellings in Israel rose by 9.34% to ILS1,969,800 (US$531,933) in Q1 2023 from a year earlier, its eleventh consecutive quarter of y-o-y increase.4 Aug 2023
Why is Israeli property so expensive?
Limited land availability: Israel is a relatively small country with a limited amount of land available for development. This scarcity of land, particularly in desirable areas, can drive up property prices
Bulldozers in, job is half done anyway, no tenants to evict or courts. It’s now Israeli occupied, taken by force and USA supplied bombs for the demolition, USA will probably help with contracts for the rebuilding into new homes for Israelis.
"So why not keep the land they won in 1967?. Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Is this cherry picked? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.timesofisrael.com/labor-chief-michaeli-rabin-was-assassinated-with-netanyahus-cooperation/amp/ Um... QED? The fact that you choose an article is sort of the point of... (sigh) What's your point, exactly? That over half of Israel hates Netanyahu, that his rhetoric turns off the left and that Israel has politics, like most other countries? Mind. Blown." Okay then ..let's have perpetual war !  | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Is this cherry picked? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.timesofisrael.com/labor-chief-michaeli-rabin-was-assassinated-with-netanyahus-cooperation/amp/ Um... QED? The fact that you choose an article is sort of the point of... (sigh) What's your point, exactly? That over half of Israel hates Netanyahu, that his rhetoric turns off the left and that Israel has politics, like most other countries? Mind. Blown. Okay then ..let's have perpetual war ! "How do you figure that?! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Is this cherry picked? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.timesofisrael.com/labor-chief-michaeli-rabin-was-assassinated-with-netanyahus-cooperation/amp/ Um... QED? The fact that you choose an article is sort of the point of... (sigh) What's your point, exactly? That over half of Israel hates Netanyahu, that his rhetoric turns off the left and that Israel has politics, like most other countries? Mind. Blown. Okay then ..let's have perpetual war !
How do you figure that?!"Conflict has been going on since 1948 with Zionist ideals. I fully agree with what has happened in that the dehumanising of palisitinians and also Isreal dehuminising themselves to achieve atrocities. The video explains this. Perhaps the guy in the video is a loony left guy I suppose but it also explains what happened with people like yourself https://youtu.be/YVmCwhFk6Pc?si=YiO02hSJ7aSx3Ib7 I know to some extent what he's talking about because I've seen and experienced it myself.. I don't blame you for it either, it's a dark side of a human trait | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Perhaps the guy in the video is a loony left guy I suppose but it also explains what happened with people like yourself " What happened? " I don't blame you for it either, it's a dark side of a human trait " Blame for what?! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Perhaps the guy in the video is a loony left guy I suppose but it also explains what happened with people like yourself What happened? I don't blame you for it either, it's a dark side of a human trait Blame for what?!" What happened : watch the video? Don't blame you : for being drawn into the dark side of dehuminisation of others.. as explained in that video. It's inherent in humans I am against colonialism, apartheid, ethnic cleansing, land/homes being plundered by any country on any groups of people. I also find it obsurd that people are still finding excuses in history in justifying what Isreal is doing to the palisitinians now! Today!.. accepting that starving people to death is okay and necessary to take revenge on innocent people. Well for me .... it isn't okay! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... " What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what?" People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what?" Oh and not just me but.. lots of others who don't get drawn into narratives from war criminals | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"There was no pearl clutching during the human right abusing assad syrian conflict the uk was funding and supporting the rebels with 100s of thousand dead or displaced, Lybia was the same." Depends on what suits the USA and UK narrative of the day. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"There was no pearl clutching during the human right abusing assad syrian conflict the uk was funding and supporting the rebels with 100s of thousand dead or displaced, Lybia was the same. Depends on what suits the USA and UK narrative of the day. " The public were silently watching it happen no out cry or protests, I fail to see the difference people being killed and displaced, must of been the wrong type of people for the public to sympathise. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable " During WW2, the Allies deliberately bombed civilians and over half a million died as a result. The outcome of the war was necessary, but we could still argue this was an unnecessary killing of innocent people. Israel do not deliberately target civilians. Yes they get killed, but that is at the hands of Hamas who build military capability into civilians infrastructure. It is not a genocide. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Conflict has been going on since 1948 with Zionist ideals." it's been going on since Arabs started attacking Jews in the 1920s. Of course, Jews were mistreated prior to that, but the attack on Zionists were not about humanitarian issues to start with - they happened because Muslims in the Middle East do not like Jews having autonomy. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable During WW2, the Allies deliberately bombed civilians and over half a million died as a result. The outcome of the war was necessary, but we could still argue this was an unnecessary killing of innocent people. Israel do not deliberately target civilians. Yes they get killed, but that is at the hands of Hamas who build military capability into civilians infrastructure. It is not a genocide." If you read history s bit more thoroughly you'll find a lot more that doesn't fit your narrative | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable " It's a shame Hamas never considered those points before October 7th | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"If you read history s bit more thoroughly you'll find a lot more that doesn't fit your narrative " Can you be specific? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable " Genocide is wrong and morally unacceptable. Who is suggesting that atrocities are acceptable? Apologists for Hamas? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable Genocide is wrong and morally unacceptable. Who is suggesting that atrocities are acceptable? Apologists for Hamas?" Your accusing me of being an hamas supporter now? It does seem that the Isreali narrative, lies and misinformation have worked a treat treat on some people. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable Genocide is wrong and morally unacceptable. Who is suggesting that atrocities are acceptable? Apologists for Hamas?" It a tad ridiculous when your talking bout Isreal.. s colonialist , racist. Apartheid country rhats illegally occupying land and ignoring all in security council resolutions. Can you tell me if palistine has any right at all to defend itself against an occupying force? hamasnwould be within their rights if they only stuck to military attacks. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Conflict has been going on since 1948 with Zionist ideals.it's been going on since Arabs started attacking Jews in the 1920s. Of course, Jews were mistreated prior to that, but the attack on Zionists were not about humanitarian issues to start with - they happened because Muslims in the Middle East do not like Jews having autonomy." Ah yes. The Balfour mandate carried out by the British, 2hen Arabs had the ordacity to be pissed off at that and riot | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"If you read history s bit more thoroughly you'll find a lot more that doesn't fit your narrative Can you be specific?" When Britain promised the Jewish Zionists th land in Palestine in the Balfour Declaration it also promised to safeguard the rights of the other existing ‘non-Jewish communities’ so that's yet another betrayal. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I actually find it extraordinary that a colonial, racist aphartied country that's occupying land it invaded illegally is being supported by so many people. What part of that seems to allude discussion? " *Ellude | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable Genocide is wrong and morally unacceptable. Who is suggesting that atrocities are acceptable? Apologists for Hamas? Your accusing me of being an hamas supporter now? " Huh? Nope. Learn to read. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I actually find it extraordinary that a colonial, racist aphartied country that's occupying land it invaded illegally is being supported by so many people. What part of that seems to allude discussion? *Ellude" *Elude Learn to write. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"pile on." Are you suggesting that Calico/Dan's seven messages fired off, in quick succession, accusing people of saying things that they didn't is somehow a pile on? Go easy on the guy. It wasn't. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"pile on." Not seeing a pile on? A pile on is when a discussion is underway between two people and then more people join in to attack one of the two. However, it depends on the nature and tone of the posts. Simply joining a conversation to politely ask questions or get clarity, or even to correct factual mistakes, is not a pile on. The key word is “attack” although you could also include ridicule. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Basic stance, if its on YouTube or twitter, it's propaganda. " Yup, it's evident those channels are increasingly used for propaganda. Even YT comments sections is obviously infiltrated by propaganda trolls. Even main stream outlets like Sky and Verizon have glaring bias. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"If you read history s bit more thoroughly you'll find a lot more that doesn't fit your narrative Can you be specific? When Britain promised the Jewish Zionists th land in Palestine in the Balfour Declaration it also promised to safeguard the rights of the other existing ‘non-Jewish communities’ so that's yet another betrayal." That was not the issue you quoted me on though. I said that Israel does not deliberately target civilians and that it is not a genocide. But, to humour you - the Balfour Declaration was not the 'be all and end all' of this. Jews were seen as second-class citizens in the Middle East for centuries. FFS, there were massacres way before the first Zionists set foot there (Hebron 1834 for example). The campaign for Jews to return to their homeland started before it got approval by the British; Jews were already buying up large swathes of land, irrigating it and farming it and employing local labour - as such, it would probably have happened anyway. But, when Britain was given the Mandate for Palestine, they were obligated by law to fulfill the declaration. However, they couldn't - the best the British could do was with the creation of Transjordan in 1922, effectively splitting Palestine in half (they banned all Jewish settling there too btw). But, too many of the local Arabs had become radicalised by antisemitic ideology spread by The Grand Mufti, Haj amin al Husseini, and because we were skint from WW2, we just couldn't sustain the pressure of being attacked from both sides. As such we left in 1948, and Israel declared its nation status immediately after - roughly a year later it was voted into the United Nations. You shouldn't make assumptions that I do not know the history. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I actually find it extraordinary that a colonial, racist aphartied country that's occupying land it invaded illegally is being supported by so many people. What part of that seems to allude discussion?" 20% of the Israeli population are not Jewish, and these people have the same rights as anyone else in the country. Compare that with the surrounding ethno-states that kicked out all their Jews. On some level, I think Israel needs to annex Judea and Samaria (The West Bank) - but, that would mean offering citizenship to terrorists, so not exactly practical at this time - however, if this was to happen, they could start treating crimimals under civil law rather than military law. A refugee movement is not an invasion. Would you say that we're being 'invaded' by refugees in the UK? Tha vast majority of Jews on this planet live in Israel - and the majority of those have modern Middle-Eastern heritage. What do you think would happen if Israel was destroyed - reallistically, what would happen? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I actually find it extraordinary that a colonial, racist aphartied country that's occupying land it invaded illegally is being supported by so many people. What part of that seems to allude discussion? 20% of the Israeli population are not Jewish, and these people have the same rights as anyone else in the country. Compare that with the surrounding ethno-states that kicked out all their Jews. On some level, I think Israel needs to annex Judea and Samaria (The West Bank) - but, that would mean offering citizenship to terrorists, so not exactly practical at this time - however, if this was to happen, they could start treating crimimals under civil law rather than military law. A refugee movement is not an invasion. Would you say that we're being 'invaded' by refugees in the UK? Tha vast majority of Jews on this planet live in Israel - and the majority of those have modern Middle-Eastern heritage. What do you think would happen if Israel was destroyed - reallistically, what would happen?" Modern Middle Eastern heritage! You mean polish, hungry Eastern European etc etc | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Modern Middle Eastern heritage! You mean polish, hungry Eastern European etc etc " No, the majority of Jews in Israel have heritage in the Islamic countries they fled or were expelled from in the last 75 years. The Jews with European heritage still have DNA that can be traced back to the ancient Middle East, but these are no longer a majority. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"pile on. Not seeing a pile on? A pile on is when a discussion is underway between two people and then more people join in to attack one of the two. However, it depends on the nature and tone of the posts. Simply joining a conversation to politely ask questions or get clarity, or even to correct factual mistakes, is not a pile on. The key word is “attack” although you could also include ridicule." Just as long as you knew what I meant, and who I was referring to as I did not mention names. But I suppose theirs safety in numbers. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I actually find it extraordinary that a colonial, racist aphartied country that's occupying land it invaded illegally is being supported by so many people. What part of that seems to allude discussion? *Ellude *Elude Learn to write." Oh dear! Your resorting to that now! Lol  | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"pile on. Are you suggesting that Calico/Dan's seven messages fired off, in quick succession, accusing people of saying things that they didn't is somehow a pile on? Go easy on the guy. It wasn't." Read your posts!... You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him. You then proceed to scoff another guy who survived the concentration camps video who also critised the Zionist ideology.. And you now say I post inaccuracies about what you said.. And now you're criticising me for posting off 6 posts (not 7 if you check) as one was deleted. Perhaps Learning to count would be a good idea | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable It's a shame Hamas never considered those points before October 7th" 7 October again!? Terrorism didn't just start on 7 October.. If you want to go down the "who started this" game then look back to the many war crimes committed by Isreal in the past 70 odd years. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Read your posts!... You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him. " You really are a special one, aren't you? At no point was there any scoffing at orthodox Jews in general. Neturei Karta do not represent orthodox Jews. That's like saying that someone who opposes Islamic State is anti Muslim. If your cannot get your head around that, then think of it this way: You say you're anti Zionist but not anti Jewish. Because Zionists do not necessarily represent Jews. It's possible to see Neturei Karta as a bunch of nutjobs (which is how almost all orthodox Jews view them) whilst maintaining respect for orthodox Jews in general. The fact that you don't know this suggests you really should not be posting videos by them. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable It's a shame Hamas never considered those points before October 7th 7 October again!? Terrorism didn't just start on 7 October.. If you want to go down the "who started this" game then look back to the many war crimes committed by Isreal in the past 70 odd years." Perhaps. But the casus belli was on 7 October. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him." I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years. If you hold onto a fringe opinion, you get stuck in ideology and you're unlikely to understand or tolerate the ideas of those who differ. This man demonstrates a very narrow interpretation of The Torah/Talmud and is not representative of the majority of Jews, especially not the Jews I grew up around in East London. As was mentioned before, by someone in another thread, cherry picking fringe opinions is not evidence of anything. If you based your opinions on your own learning, rather than the opinions of people with extremist ideas, then maybe you'd be on a different page. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Read your posts!... You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him. You really are a special one, aren't you? At no point was there any scoffing at orthodox Jews in general. Neturei Karta do not represent orthodox Jews. That's like saying that someone who opposes Islamic State is anti Muslim. If your cannot get your head around that, then think of it this way: You say you're anti Zionist but not anti Jewish. Because Zionists do not necessarily represent Jews. It's possible to see Neturei Karta as a bunch of nutjobs (which is how almost all orthodox Jews view them) whilst maintaining respect for orthodox Jews in general. The fact that you don't know this suggests you really should not be posting videos by them." You think what you like! I would choose the path of the orthodox Jews any day of the week, rather than your pro war pro suffering pro violence.. which both sides are getting! Both Isreal and palistine. You just don't get it do you! I'll be generous.. I'll put in s spelling mysttake for you to rant over , while you rant on how knowledgeable you *think* you are. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him. I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years. If you hold onto a fringe opinion, you get stuck in ideology and you're unlikely to understand or tolerate the ideas of those who differ. This man demonstrates a very narrow interpretation of The Torah/Talmud and is not representative of the majority of Jews, especially not the Jews I grew up around in East London. As was mentioned before, by someone in another thread, cherry picking fringe opinions is not evidence of anything. If you based your opinions on your own learning, rather than the opinions of people with extremist ideas, then maybe you'd be on a different page. " Perhaps then you could label the Jews against the war as all fringe groups too. The ones with "not in my name" t shirts on. I'm no expert in th religious arguments but I do know Isreal's activity over the decades and I also know the difference between right and wrong | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" You think what you like! " Thank you. That is very magnanimous of you. " I would choose the path of the orthodox Jews any day of the week, rather than your pro war pro suffering pro violence.. which both sides are getting! Both Isreal and palistine. You just don't get it do you! " Pro war. Pro suffering. Pro violence. Those are heavy charges. Click the green arrow and find posts that demonstrate any of those. *Actually* any of those, not oblique inferences. Defending Israel's right to self defense is not pro war. Pointing out that Hamas bears much responsibility for provoking an Israeli attack is not pro suffering. And positing that the legal threshold for genocide has not been met is not pro violence. So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years. If you hold onto a fringe opinion, you get stuck in ideology and you're unlikely to understand or tolerate the ideas of those who differ. If you based your opinions on your own learning, rather than the opinions of people with extremist ideas, then maybe you'd be on a different page. " This made me laugh. Fab’s finest on this thread | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him. I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years. If you hold onto a fringe opinion, you get stuck in ideology and you're unlikely to understand or tolerate the ideas of those who differ. This man demonstrates a very narrow interpretation of The Torah/Talmud and is not representative of the majority of Jews, especially not the Jews I grew up around in East London. As was mentioned before, by someone in another thread, cherry picking fringe opinions is not evidence of anything. If you based your opinions on your own learning, rather than the opinions of people with extremist ideas, then maybe you'd be on a different page. " Those are your opinions.. and it's a big if!. Your also assuming my remark was made at you.. in that case your opinionated, or your interceding.. but in either case I follow the foundation of what's morally right. I don't quote obscure waffle in an attempt to justify what's morally wrong or right.. Some people's arses must be jealous of their mouths with the crap uttered on here to defend Isreal's activities. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years " I'm not an expert in religion, but I understand bullcrap when I see it to justify genocide and ethnic cleansing that's plainly and obviously Morally wrong! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" You think what you like! Thank you. That is very magnanimous of you. I would choose the path of the orthodox Jews any day of the week, rather than your pro war pro suffering pro violence.. which both sides are getting! Both Isreal and palistine. You just don't get it do you! Pro war. Pro suffering. Pro violence. Those are heavy charges. Click the green arrow and find posts that demonstrate any of those. *Actually* any of those, not oblique inferences. Defending Israel's right to self defense is not pro war. Pointing out that Hamas bears much responsibility for provoking an Israeli attack is not pro suffering. And positing that the legal threshold for genocide has not been met is not pro violence. So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made." Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Because this conflict has dragged on for years! It didn't start on 7 October! Isreal's failed tactic to bomb straffe and starve people they invaded hasn't worked in decades! Isreal was born out of land theft, not being content with the land the UK helped steal to create Isreal. They want even more land! The only way Isreal will get security is if palistine gets its own security to live in peace.. and I think it's gone too far now for that. Hasn't palistine been treated badly enough ? I doubt you think so.. Some people on here have the ordacity to justify starving Children and babies ffs!! And people expect me to accept that utter bullcrap? I don't think so | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You scoff orthodox Jews .. as if you know more about Judaism than him. I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years. If you hold onto a fringe opinion, you get stuck in ideology and you're unlikely to understand or tolerate the ideas of those who differ. This man demonstrates a very narrow interpretation of The Torah/Talmud and is not representative of the majority of Jews, especially not the Jews I grew up around in East London. As was mentioned before, by someone in another thread, cherry picking fringe opinions is not evidence of anything. If you based your opinions on your own learning, rather than the opinions of people with extremist ideas, then maybe you'd be on a different page. " I read something you posted, stating that orthodox Jews don't accept Zionism because they want a bigger state than Isreal. If that's correct, why did he state that he stands with the palisitinians being persecuted and his religion was being hijacked by far right violent extremists. You being an expert on religion you will no doubt have an answer. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable It's a shame Hamas never considered those points before October 7th 7 October again!? Terrorism didn't just start on 7 October.. If you want to go down the "who started this" game then look back to the many war crimes committed by Isreal in the past 70 odd years." I did not make any claims as to who started what and when | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable It's a shame Hamas never considered those points before October 7th 7 October again!? Terrorism didn't just start on 7 October.. If you want to go down the "who started this" game then look back to the many war crimes committed by Isreal in the past 70 odd years. I did not make any claims as to who started what and when" Okay.. but in any event I rek too much has happened for any peace agreement. Especially with the leadership | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. " Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up... | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years I'm not an expert in religion, but I understand bullcrap when I see it to justify genocide and ethnic cleansing that's plainly and obviously Morally wrong! " Except you are wrong and a sovereign state responding to an act of war by removing a clear threat is not genocide. Israel have been accused of genocide since forever, and yet the population of Palestine just keeps growing. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up..." Well your statements are the usual stuff.. defending isreali even when the UN findings don't match your rhetoric. Incidentally, Ireland is now backing up South Africanin reffering isrea to the ICC. I suppose they're wrong to do that too. Btw I did click 9n your green arrow and wasn't surprised at the pro Zionist support you have. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I'm not even Jewish and I understand it more than him. Comparitive religion and human beliefs have been special interest topic of mine for many years I'm not an expert in religion, but I understand bullcrap when I see it to justify genocide and ethnic cleansing that's plainly and obviously Morally wrong! Except you are wrong and a sovereign state responding to an act of war by removing a clear threat is not genocide. Israel have been accused of genocide since forever, and yet the population of Palestine just keeps growing." Well it's obvious Isreali infanticidal, genocidal regime Is doing well and has support. I wonder if Putin could pull off spouting the same crap that Isreal has and get away with it too? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up..." You need to give your head s wobble.. I've just been looking at the pro Zionist comments you've been posting | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up... You need to give your head s wobble.. I've just been looking at the pro Zionist comments you've been posting" Oh, good. Keep reading. Report back when you have something tangible about which to complain. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up... You need to give your head s wobble.. I've just been looking at the pro Zionist comments you've been posting Oh, good. Keep reading. Report back when you have something tangible about which to complain." Oh I'm not complaining.. it's rather revealing that your duplicitous in your statements. You've a heavy leaning towards spouting isreali propoganda. If anyone else is reading this then don't take my word for it. click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up... You need to give your head s wobble.. I've just been looking at the pro Zionist comments you've been posting Oh, good. Keep reading. Report back when you have something tangible about which to complain. Oh I'm not complaining.. it's rather revealing that your duplicitous in your statements. You've a heavy leaning towards spouting isreali propoganda. If anyone else is reading this then don't take my word for it. click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. " Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" So click that green arrow and defend the charge that you just made. Don't need to click on anything. You've already stated things like "what genocide?" In s thread somewhere.. You've also stated "why perpetual war" or something to that effect, when I said that. Yeah, you really do need to click. Otherwise you rely on your memory to make stuff up... You need to give your head s wobble.. I've just been looking at the pro Zionist comments you've been posting Oh, good. Keep reading. Report back when you have something tangible about which to complain. Oh I'm not complaining.. it's rather revealing that your duplicitous in your statements. You've a heavy leaning towards spouting isreali propoganda. If anyone else is reading this then don't take my word for it. click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it." Well this is interesting, what are you accusing me of now? Your the one supporting very questionable actions committed by isreal | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it. Well this is interesting, what are you accusing me of now? Your the one supporting very questionable actions committed by isreal " Huh? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Well it's obvious Isreali infanticidal, genocidal regime Is doing well and has support. I wonder if Putin could pull off spouting the same crap that Isreal has and get away with it too? " During WW2, the Allies killed over half a million civilians in bombing raids - and in this case they really did target civilians with impunity. Do you think it was wrong to defeat the Nazis too? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Well it's obvious Isreali infanticidal, genocidal regime Is doing well and has support. I wonder if Putin could pull off spouting the same crap that Isreal has and get away with it too? During WW2, the Allies killed over half a million civilians in bombing raids - and in this case they really did target civilians with impunity. Do you think it was wrong to defeat the Nazis too?" That's right, we couldn't defeat the nazi forces without mass killing huge numbers of innocent civilians. Ergo Israel should execute as many Palestinian kids as possible. Sterling work all round. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it. Well this is interesting, what are you accusing me of now? Your the one supporting very questionable actions committed by isreal Huh?" Well it's not a good reply lol.. click your green arrow and read what you've written | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Well it's obvious Isreali infanticidal, genocidal regime Is doing well and has support. I wonder if Putin could pull off spouting the same crap that Isreal has and get away with it too? During WW2, the Allies killed over half a million civilians in bombing raids - and in this case they really did target civilians with impunity. Do you think it was wrong to defeat the Nazis too?" I agree with you, the Nazis invaders of other countries in Europe, but in this case Isreal doing the invading .. Btw you haven't answered my question; why is palistine not allowed to defend itself against an invading force? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it. Well this is interesting, what are you accusing me of now? Your the one supporting very questionable actions committed by isreal Huh? Well it's not a good reply lol.. click your green arrow and read what you've written " Okay Dan/Calico/J/etc. You are clearly a good person. You see injustice and suffering and have a visceral reaction to it. Your heart is big and you clearly feel passionately. Where we differ is in both perspective and communication style. We discuss things differently and evidently we don't understand each other. Discussions between us are very much at cross purposes. You clearly thought that there was an accusation against you somewhere there - there wasn't. It's not the first time that this kind of thing has happened. We clearly have different communication styles that are incompatible. Your heart is truly in the right place, though. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I ummed and arred about doing this but it is bugging me so I will… Palestine Not Palistine" Is you being real? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I ummed and arred about doing this but it is bugging me so I will… Palestine Not Palistine Is you being real?" I’m being a spelling pedant and I am self aware enough to know this is not really reading the mood music of the room but…it was really bothering me and sometimes I can be an asshole  | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I ummed and arred about doing this but it is bugging me so I will… Palestine Not Palistine Is you being real? I’m being a spelling pedant and I am self aware enough to know this is not really reading the mood music of the room but…it was really bothering me and sometimes I can be an asshole "Is real, then. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I ummed and arred about doing this but it is bugging me so I will… Palestine Not Palistine Is you being real? I’m being a spelling pedant and I am self aware enough to know this is not really reading the mood music of the room but…it was really bothering me and sometimes I can be an asshole
Is real, then. "Sorry I don’t get slang and I’m way to old to be down with the kids talking street (my teen tells me). So not sure what “is real, then” or “is you being real” actually means or is intended to signify
I took a guess first time  | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I ummed and arred about doing this but it is bugging me so I will… Palestine Not Palistine Is you being real? I’m being a spelling pedant and I am self aware enough to know this is not really reading the mood music of the room but…it was really bothering me and sometimes I can be an asshole
Is real, then.
Sorry I don’t get slang and I’m way to old to be down with the kids talking street (my teen tells me). So not sure what “is real, then” or “is you being real” actually means or is intended to signify
I took a guess first time "Bloody tiny phone keyboard grrrr *too old | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I ummed and arred about doing this but it is bugging me so I will… Palestine Not Palistine Is you being real? I’m being a spelling pedant and I am self aware enough to know this is not really reading the mood music of the room but…it was really bothering me and sometimes I can be an asshole
Is real, then.
Sorry I don’t get slang and I’m way to old to be down with the kids talking street (my teen tells me). So not sure what “is real, then” or “is you being real” actually means or is intended to signify
I took a guess first time
Bloody tiny phone keyboard grrrr
*too old"Just a silly joke, really. Check the thread title | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it. Well this is interesting, what are you accusing me of now? Your the one supporting very questionable actions committed by isreal Huh? Well it's not a good reply lol.. click your green arrow and read what you've written Okay Dan/Calico/J/etc. You are clearly a good person. You see injustice and suffering and have a visceral reaction to it. Your heart is big and you clearly feel passionately. Where we differ is in both perspective and communication style. We discuss things differently and evidently we don't understand each other. Discussions between us are very much at cross purposes. You clearly thought that there was an accusation against you somewhere there - there wasn't. It's not the first time that this kind of thing has happened. We clearly have different communication styles that are incompatible. Your heart is truly in the right place, though." I think you should think twice before you post your conceited self entitled statements A UN expert says Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, and calls for arms embargo | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" A UN expert says Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, and calls for arms embargo " UN experts were also employing terrorists and allowing them to use their infrastructure. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Btw you haven't answered my question; why is palistine not allowed to defend itself against an invading force? " Name the sovereign countries that Israel has invaded without being provoked. Now, ask yourself how they invaded, what armaments they used, who their army was made up of and, importantly, why they 'invaded'? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" A UN expert says Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, and calls for arms embargo UN experts were also employing terrorists and allowing them to use their infrastructure." Tik tok army is terrorist organisation. Committing genocide in the name of religion. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Tik tok army is terrorist organisation. Committing genocide in the name of religion." No idea what you mean by that tbh. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"This is all about Netanyahu's desperate grip to power. Strong parallels with Putin's forays into Ukraine. The man will do anything including ethnic cleansing and war crimes. All eyes on Gaza but events in West Bank tells you a lot about where the conflict is heading. This is about land and territory. " | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Btw you haven't answered my question; why is palistine not allowed to defend itself against an invading force? Name the sovereign countries that Israel has invaded without being provoked. Now, ask yourself how they invaded, what armaments they used, who their army was made up of and, importantly, why they 'invaded'?" Why is that relevent?! The only relevant fact is the UN has endless lists of war crimes and recently found Isreal to be using starvation and genocide! I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Btw you haven't answered my question; why is palistine not allowed to defend itself against an invading force? Name the sovereign countries that Israel has invaded without being provoked. Now, ask yourself how they invaded, what armaments they used, who their army was made up of and, importantly, why they 'invaded'?" "Provoked " is an ambiguous word based on opinion.. A paranoid aggressive person or country will have any excuse to attack another | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" Btw you haven't answered my question; why is palistine not allowed to defend itself against an invading force? Name the sovereign countries that Israel has invaded without being provoked. Now, ask yourself how they invaded, what armaments they used, who their army was made up of and, importantly, why they 'invaded'? "Provoked " is an ambiguous word based on opinion.. A paranoid aggressive person or country will have any excuse to attack another " It's a very clear word. Now answer the question. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? " I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God." I don't doubt that Islam has a brutal side, but it doesn't justify calling them "animals" then setting ourselves onto pedastals as shining examples to be forced onto other cultures! That's been tried in Iraq and Afghanistan.. a failed experiment. I've seen Western attitudes and treatment of local afghans.. and an American seargen playing a bit fast and loose with some. Remember abu ghraib prison? The pics, the brutality? Your just as bad as Islam if that's your thoughts. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" click ont the poster's green arrow and read it for yourselves. Please do. Quote (don't paraphrase into a straw man) the reprehensible content and either report it or challenge it. Well this is interesting, what are you accusing me of now? Your the one supporting very questionable actions committed by isreal Huh? Well it's not a good reply lol.. click your green arrow and read what you've written Okay Dan/Calico/J/etc. You are clearly a good person. You see injustice and suffering and have a visceral reaction to it. Your heart is big and you clearly feel passionately. Where we differ is in both perspective and communication style. We discuss things differently and evidently we don't understand each other. Discussions between us are very much at cross purposes. You clearly thought that there was an accusation against you somewhere there - there wasn't. It's not the first time that this kind of thing has happened. We clearly have different communication styles that are incompatible. Your heart is truly in the right place, though. I think you should think twice before you post your conceited self entitled statements A UN expert says Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, and calls for arms embargo " The call for an arms embargo is due to the Israeli government handing out pistols and automatic weapons in the West Bank to the jewish population who have settled there. And the call for Palestinians to defend themselves comes from the use of these weapons against Palestinians in the West Bank. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God." Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ?" In the last 30 years? Even 50 years? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ?" In instances were religion was actual quoted as the reason for the killing? Can you please tell us? Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" doesn't justify calling them "animals" " I did not call them animals - please do not misquote me. To be honest, I'm a vegan, I have more respect for animals. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? In the last 30 years? Even 50 years?" That is the key point here when someone says “ah yeah but…!” We need to focus on the modern era. 20th & 21st Century should cover it. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? In the last 30 years? Even 50 years? That is the key point here when someone says “ah yeah but…!” We need to focus on the modern era. 20th & 21st Century should cover it. " The poster said other religions had gone through reforms, only to be told Christianity has killed 'many', but when, that's absolutely key. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? In the last 30 years? Even 50 years? That is the key point here when someone says “ah yeah but…!” We need to focus on the modern era. 20th & 21st Century should cover it. The poster said other religions had gone through reforms, only to be told Christianity has killed 'many', but when, that's absolutely key. " Indeed I agree. I was just doubling your timeframe to emphasise even more what a poor attempt at whataboutism they were trying. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? In the last 30 years? Even 50 years? That is the key point here when someone says “ah yeah but…!” We need to focus on the modern era. 20th & 21st Century should cover it. The poster said other religions had gone through reforms, only to be told Christianity has killed 'many', but when, that's absolutely key. Indeed I agree. I was just doubling your timeframe to emphasise even more what a poor attempt at whataboutism they were trying." Double it, triple it, quadruple it. I still don't think Christianity would compare to Islam. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? In the last 30 years? Even 50 years? That is the key point here when someone says “ah yeah but…!” We need to focus on the modern era. 20th & 21st Century should cover it. The poster said other religions had gone through reforms, only to be told Christianity has killed 'many', but when, that's absolutely key. Indeed I agree. I was just doubling your timeframe to emphasise even more what a poor attempt at whataboutism they were trying. Double it, triple it, quadruple it. I still don't think Christianity would compare to Islam. " I don’t know. It is undoubtable that many have died throughout history in the name of Christianity. But not in the modern era which supports the “Christianity has reformed vs Islam has not” point someone made. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I reckon , for some reason you have a bit of a chip on your shoulder regarding Muslims. Have you a hidden agenda against them.? I think Islam is a misogynistic, homophobic and oppressive religion that either needs to reform or be done away with. I'm not talking about the people, or the non-observant secular types, I'm talking about the ideology - and while oppressive ideas exist in other religions, they went through their reforms generations ago. As far as I am aware, Islam is the only religion that still practices their medieval ideas - you don't find Jews or Christians throwing people from rooftops in the name of God. Would you hazard a guess how many people have been killed in the name of Christianity ? In the last 30 years? Even 50 years? That is the key point here when someone says “ah yeah but…!” We need to focus on the modern era. 20th & 21st Century should cover it. The poster said other religions had gone through reforms, only to be told Christianity has killed 'many', but when, that's absolutely key. Indeed I agree. I was just doubling your timeframe to emphasise even more what a poor attempt at whataboutism they were trying. Double it, triple it, quadruple it. I still don't think Christianity would compare to Islam. I don’t know. It is undoubtable that many have died throughout history in the name of Christianity. But not in the modern era which supports the “Christianity has reformed vs Islam has not” point someone made." Agreed. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"The bombing of the world central kitchen aid workers by the IDF isn’t going to help their current situation….. They are about as trustworthy as it gets…… especially since they coordinated with the IDF and had their symbols all over the cars involved The only saving grace for Isreal is they have admitted this one straight away! " But it smacks of “we are out of control and enraged with blood lust” on the part of the IDF/Israeli govt. They need to stop and take stock. Surely this tells them that? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"The bombing of the world central kitchen aid workers by the IDF isn’t going to help their current situation….. They are about as trustworthy as it gets…… especially since they coordinated with the IDF and had their symbols all over the cars involved The only saving grace for Isreal is they have admitted this one straight away! " Sympathy for 7 October waning Israel are the terrorists now. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"The bombing of the world central kitchen aid workers by the IDF isn’t going to help their current situation….. They are about as trustworthy as it gets…… especially since they coordinated with the IDF and had their symbols all over the cars involved The only saving grace for Isreal is they have admitted this one straight away! But it smacks of “we are out of control and enraged with blood lust” on the part of the IDF/Israeli govt. They need to stop and take stock. Surely this tells them that?" Because unfortunately the victims came from lots of different countries.. the uk, Australia, Canada, the USA.. it might just slow them down a bit I thought the bombing of the consulate was going to be the big no no today… this just compounds it If Isreal call bombing embassies and consulates legitimate targets, then this just went truly truly global…. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Three British aid workers now reported killed in the Israeli airstrike on the humanitarian aid convoy in Gaza" Israel are making defence of their actions very hard to defend, I see. Apparently the IDF are targeting medical staff, witness have stated that staff were found handcuffed with gunshot wounds to the head. The IDF were asked for comment but they pulled out of the interview with Nick Ferrari so there is no defence or reasoning from the IDF. Make of that what you will. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Three British aid workers now reported killed in the Israeli airstrike on the humanitarian aid convoy in Gaza Israel are making defence of their actions very hard to defend, I see. Apparently the IDF are targeting medical staff, witness have stated that staff were found handcuffed with gunshot wounds to the head. The IDF were asked for comment but they pulled out of the interview with Nick Ferrari so there is no defence or reasoning from the IDF. Make of that what you will." If true then as per my point above, they are out of control! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"I wonder if those aid workers where murdered with US weapons?" Which country sells the most weapons to Israel? 'The U.S. is followed by France, Russia, China, Germany, Italy, United Kingdom and Spain. The world's tenth-largest arms exporter is South Korea. Israel imports its weapons from the U.S. (69%) and Germany (30%), while also buying 0.9% from Italy.' Could be any of them really couldn't it? And for perspective . . . 'Israel is the ninth-largest arms exporter in the world, according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute's (SIPRI) new annual report. Over the past four years' | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"IDF soldiers mocking the death of World central Kitchen workers on their telegram channels which includes three British aid workers. Just goes to show the real face of most moral army." The more I hear about the attack, the more angry I get 3 separate air strikes targeting 3 separate cars one after another…. The cars in the convoy were distanced, and the IDF knew exactly what was happening It does feel deliberate and the consequences are exactly what Israel wanted You hear Israel “express sorrow ” but I have yet to actually hear a spokesperson actually say the word “sorry”… staggering, the interview of the spokesperson on channel 4 last night was horrendous | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"IDF soldiers mocking the death of World central Kitchen workers on their telegram channels which includes three British aid workers. Just goes to show the real face of most moral army. The more I hear about the attack, the more angry I get 3 separate air strikes targeting 3 separate cars one after another…. The cars in the convoy were distanced, and the IDF knew exactly what was happening It does feel deliberate and the consequences are exactly what Israel wanted You hear Israel “express sorrow ” but I have yet to actually hear a spokesperson actually say the word “sorry”… staggering, the interview of the spokesperson on channel 4 last night was horrendous " Me too. If accounts are true the convoy was chased and hunted down like dogs. No accident at all. Disgraceful. Rishi still sitting on his hands mind. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"IDF soldiers mocking the death of World central Kitchen workers on their telegram channels which includes three British aid workers. Just goes to show the real face of most moral army. The more I hear about the attack, the more angry I get 3 separate air strikes targeting 3 separate cars one after another…. The cars in the convoy were distanced, and the IDF knew exactly what was happening It does feel deliberate and the consequences are exactly what Israel wanted You hear Israel “express sorrow ” but I have yet to actually hear a spokesperson actually say the word “sorry”… staggering, the interview of the spokesperson on channel 4 last night was horrendous " Yes I fully agree. The main aim is to prevent food water and any othe aid reaching anyone. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"IDF soldiers mocking the death of World central Kitchen workers on their telegram channels which includes three British aid workers. Just goes to show the real face of most moral army. The more I hear about the attack, the more angry I get 3 separate air strikes targeting 3 separate cars one after another…. The cars in the convoy were distanced, and the IDF knew exactly what was happening It does feel deliberate and the consequences are exactly what Israel wanted You hear Israel “express sorrow ” but I have yet to actually hear a spokesperson actually say the word “sorry”… staggering, the interview of the spokesperson on channel 4 last night was horrendous Yes I fully agree. The main aim is to prevent food water and any othe aid reaching anyone." I also agree, as aid relief has been suspended, I also saw the car crash interview, were I discovered that 169 aid workers have been murdered, the BBC sight 193 aid workers murdered either way aid workers are being murdered. And the killing continue Israel are finished and I wonder were the vocal Israel has the right spokespeople are? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"British nationals murdered by Israeli terrorists Stop selling them arms Ban their imports Ban visas to Israelis coming to uk Come on Sunak grow a pair. " Sunak has American permanent resident green card status he doesn't want to rock the boat by having a spine. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Holocaust is the genocidal crime against people based on their ethnicity. This genocide could be perpetrated through different means such as poison gas, guns, tanks, air raids, biological warfare, economical siege, starvation, destruction of vital natural resources, eviction into desert, and deprivation of basic vital materials among others, to produce the same result; mass deaths. For the last 75 years Palestinians have been suffering from all these methods in a deliberate programmed holocaust. The perpetrators are not Nazis, but those who claim to be survivors, and their descendents, of Nazi-caused holocaust; Zionist Israelis. This holocaust did not target only Gaza, although Gaza is now suffering its main assault, but also targeted every Palestinian community in the West Bank. Netanyahu no different from Hitler." You seem to not be able to help yourself. You are in capable of forming any balanced arguments, cherry picking things to suit your anti Jewish narrative. It's quite sad really, Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Holocaust is the genocidal crime against people based on their ethnicity. This genocide could be perpetrated through different means such as poison gas, guns, tanks, air raids, biological warfare, economical siege, starvation, destruction of vital natural resources, eviction into desert, and deprivation of basic vital materials among others, to produce the same result; mass deaths. For the last 75 years Palestinians have been suffering from all these methods in a deliberate programmed holocaust. The perpetrators are not Nazis, but those who claim to be survivors, and their descendents, of Nazi-caused holocaust; Zionist Israelis. This holocaust did not target only Gaza, although Gaza is now suffering its main assault, but also targeted every Palestinian community in the West Bank. Netanyahu no different from Hitler.You seem to not be able to help yourself. You are in capable of forming any balanced arguments, cherry picking things to suit your anti Jewish narrative. It's quite sad really, Mrs x" Coming from a person who is openly calling for killing of Muslims children in your previous posts and on different threads. Calling out Israel for genocide it’s committing against innocent Palestinian women and children isn’t anti Jewish. You know your last trick in your bag isn’t working and world can see the real ugly face of Zionism. Stop playing permanent victim card when people call out for Satanyahu regime crimes. You know what really Sad is people like you who are still defending these atrocities. Israel has the right to defend itself after the killing of thousands of children" is like saying a rapist has the right to fight back when a woman punches him”. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" ...it also explains what happened with people like yourself... What do YOU mean by that. What are you saying "happened" when you say "happened with people like yourself". What are you observing about another human being that occurred, and based upon what? People are gullible and easily influenced into the narrative that attrocities are acceptable in certain circumstances. Genocide.and facilitating genocide even with excuses from war criminals is just as wrong and morally unacceptable It's a shame Hamas never considered those points before October 7th" I think they did, as did Iran who sanctioned and encouraged it. They never cared about the casualties of what was going to happen....they all knew exactly what Israel would do, they just never expected Israel to go through with it till the end as they thought world pressure would stop Israel. Way back in Nov I posted in here Israel would not stop till they finished the job and I that it would spread across the region. Iran will not take it much further but needed to save face in the region so had to retaliate but they know they cannot afford to go up against Israel yet without proper nuclear weapons to match Israels. Plus they know they would draw the US further into it. This is far far more than Netanyahu. This is about 5000+ years of history, land, culture and identity of which few really grasp it's significance. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I thought the bombing of the consulate was going to be the big no no today… this just compounds it If Isreal call bombing embassies and consulates legitimate targets, then this just went truly truly global…. " Coming back to this from 1 week ago.. I thought this would be the red line… Now Isreal have basically shut down everything for the next 3 days citing they are expecting the response from Israel So the question is… do the missile/s come from the north via Lebanon and Syria, the south via Yemen… or direct ( interesting Jordan have just closed their entire airspace…. I wonder if they will try and shoot down any missiles going through in either direction!) Iran are going to make Isreal twist in the wind not knowing which defence they are going to have to sure up! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
" I thought the bombing of the consulate was going to be the big no no today… this just compounds it If Isreal call bombing embassies and consulates legitimate targets, then this just went truly truly global…. Coming back to this from 1 week ago.. I thought this would be the red line… Now Isreal have basically shut down everything for the next 3 days citing they are expecting the response from Israel So the question is… do the missile/s come from the north via Lebanon and Syria, the south via Yemen… or direct ( interesting Jordan have just closed their entire airspace…. I wonder if they will try and shoot down any missiles going through in either direction!) Iran are going to make Isreal twist in the wind not knowing which defence they are going to have to sure up! " Since you wrote this, bbc reporting the Iranian drones are in the skies on their way, possibly in conjunction with ballistic missiles. Will have to see tmrw what the IDF air force and two US strike carriers do next, over 200 war planes between them | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Not sure whether you can't read or if you are just stupid. Think it must be stupid.... I've never said I wanted anyone killed. I've said all innocent lives lost on both sides is a terrible tragedy. The language you use and your arguments are infantile at best. You call Jews Zionists, when in reality most Jews living in Israel today or secular,non observant individuals. But you continue ue with Zionist because of the negative co notations you try to utilise to back up your ridiculous claims. Not sure if you've read any history but comparing a tone to Hitler is a stupid statement. It's how's how biased you are. Hitler killed millions of Jews. Not just Ziinistd like you want to claim but ordinary, moderate Jews, secular Jews, men, woman and children. Only other dictators are comparable, such as Stalin, Mao and the like. I ask you to provide a balanced, more rounded view, it makes it more interesting for the reader. For example, the latest tragedy involving the killing of aid workers is just that, an absolute tragedy and I feel so much sympathy for their families and love ones for their terrible loss. I cannot say whether this was a deliberate act by Israel or was, as they suggest, an operational accident. No body other those who committed the acts no the truth. And let me state this again I do not think it should have ever happened, whatever the truth. But when I talk of a more rounded, balanced view, I mean you should acknowledge similar things committed by both groups. Yet you just rant about one side,going as far as comparing their leader as Satan... So the killing of three aid workers is a tragedy we can both agree on. However when people me lion any facts which don't suit your narrative you seem to saying all lies and not the same. Soon in the interests of balance, are the murders of innocent contractors, supplying aid to the Middle East, justified a tragedy in the same way as these latest tragedies are? For context Muslim terrorist groups killed almost 800, yes 800 civilians who were supplying things such as food, water, electricity, infrastructure and medical supplies and services. This rose to over 1500 innocent civilians who were murdered by Muslim terrorist groups. This includes over 350 Americans and almost 60 Brits These weren't involved in military conflicts, crossfireetc. And I'm not saying that the three aid workers deaths were caused like this. I'm just saying g one said aid it was, one side said it wasn't. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with either explanation, ijust don't know. However it's harder to say the others didn't suffer murder atthe handsome one particular group, given that they were dragged out and shot, tortured, kept them captive and then killed. A significant number were beheaded, had their deaths posted on line. So if you are going to post something reference both sides, otherwise you a just a religious zealot and anti semite, Mrs x" Another example if contratictory bull spouted out. this time in the same post | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Not sure whether you can't read or if you are just stupid. Think it must be stupid.... I've never said I wanted anyone killed. I've said all innocent lives lost on both sides is a terrible tragedy. The language you use and your arguments are infantile at best. You call Jews Zionists, when in reality most Jews living in Israel today or secular,non observant individuals. But you continue ue with Zionist because of the negative co notations you try to utilise to back up your ridiculous claims. Not sure if you've read any history but comparing a tone to Hitler is a stupid statement. It's how's how biased you are. Hitler killed millions of Jews. Not just Ziinistd like you want to claim but ordinary, moderate Jews, secular Jews, men, woman and children. Only other dictators are comparable, such as Stalin, Mao and the like. I ask you to provide a balanced, more rounded view, it makes it more interesting for the reader. For example, the latest tragedy involving the killing of aid workers is just that, an absolute tragedy and I feel so much sympathy for their families and love ones for their terrible loss. I cannot say whether this was a deliberate act by Israel or was, as they suggest, an operational accident. No body other those who committed the acts no the truth. And let me state this again I do not think it should have ever happened, whatever the truth. But when I talk of a more rounded, balanced view, I mean you should acknowledge similar things committed by both groups. Yet you just rant about one side,going as far as comparing their leader as Satan... So the killing of three aid workers is a tragedy we can both agree on. However when people me lion any facts which don't suit your narrative you seem to saying all lies and not the same. Soon in the interests of balance, are the murders of innocent contractors, supplying aid to the Middle East, justified a tragedy in the same way as these latest tragedies are? For context Muslim terrorist groups killed almost 800, yes 800 civilians who were supplying things such as food, water, electricity, infrastructure and medical supplies and services. This rose to over 1500 innocent civilians who were murdered by Muslim terrorist groups. This includes over 350 Americans and almost 60 Brits These weren't involved in military conflicts, crossfireetc. And I'm not saying that the three aid workers deaths were caused like this. I'm just saying g one said aid it was, one side said it wasn't. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with either explanation, ijust don't know. However it's harder to say the others didn't suffer murder atthe handsome one particular group, given that they were dragged out and shot, tortured, kept them captive and then killed. A significant number were beheaded, had their deaths posted on line. So if you are going to post something reference both sides, otherwise you a just a religious zealot and anti semite, Mrs x Another example if contratictory bull spouted out. this time in the same post " So which bit is contradictory? Don't know why I bother asking, you never give answers just statement, Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Not sure whether you can't read or if you are just stupid. Think it must be stupid.... I've never said I wanted anyone killed. I've said all innocent lives lost on both sides is a terrible tragedy. The language you use and your arguments are infantile at best. You call Jews Zionists, when in reality most Jews living in Israel today or secular,non observant individuals. But you continue ue with Zionist because of the negative co notations you try to utilise to back up your ridiculous claims. Not sure if you've read any history but comparing a tone to Hitler is a stupid statement. It's how's how biased you are. Hitler killed millions of Jews. Not just Ziinistd like you want to claim but ordinary, moderate Jews, secular Jews, men, woman and children. Only other dictators are comparable, such as Stalin, Mao and the like. I ask you to provide a balanced, more rounded view, it makes it more interesting for the reader. For example, the latest tragedy involving the killing of aid workers is just that, an absolute tragedy and I feel so much sympathy for their families and love ones for their terrible loss. I cannot say whether this was a deliberate act by Israel or was, as they suggest, an operational accident. No body other those who committed the acts no the truth. And let me state this again I do not think it should have ever happened, whatever the truth. But when I talk of a more rounded, balanced view, I mean you should acknowledge similar things committed by both groups. Yet you just rant about one side,going as far as comparing their leader as Satan... So the killing of three aid workers is a tragedy we can both agree on. However when people me lion any facts which don't suit your narrative you seem to saying all lies and not the same. Soon in the interests of balance, are the murders of innocent contractors, supplying aid to the Middle East, justified a tragedy in the same way as these latest tragedies are? For context Muslim terrorist groups killed almost 800, yes 800 civilians who were supplying things such as food, water, electricity, infrastructure and medical supplies and services. This rose to over 1500 innocent civilians who were murdered by Muslim terrorist groups. This includes over 350 Americans and almost 60 Brits These weren't involved in military conflicts, crossfireetc. And I'm not saying that the three aid workers deaths were caused like this. I'm just saying g one said aid it was, one side said it wasn't. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with either explanation, ijust don't know. However it's harder to say the others didn't suffer murder atthe handsome one particular group, given that they were dragged out and shot, tortured, kept them captive and then killed. A significant number were beheaded, had their deaths posted on line. So if you are going to post something reference both sides, otherwise you a just a religious zealot and anti semite, Mrs x Another example if contratictory bull spouted out. this time in the same post So which bit is contradictory? Don't know why I bother asking, you never give answers just statement, Mrs x" You accused me of virtue signalling, then quizz me if I'm an IRA sympathiser, then scoff me sbout what I did as a medic and told me what it was like and what I did when you weren't even fucking there!? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Not sure whether you can't read or if you are just stupid. Think it must be stupid.... I've never said I wanted anyone killed. I've said all innocent lives lost on both sides is a terrible tragedy. The language you use and your arguments are infantile at best. You call Jews Zionists, when in reality most Jews living in Israel today or secular,non observant individuals. But you continue ue with Zionist because of the negative co notations you try to utilise to back up your ridiculous claims. Not sure if you've read any history but comparing a tone to Hitler is a stupid statement. It's how's how biased you are. Hitler killed millions of Jews. Not just Ziinistd like you want to claim but ordinary, moderate Jews, secular Jews, men, woman and children. Only other dictators are comparable, such as Stalin, Mao and the like. I ask you to provide a balanced, more rounded view, it makes it more interesting for the reader. For example, the latest tragedy involving the killing of aid workers is just that, an absolute tragedy and I feel so much sympathy for their families and love ones for their terrible loss. I cannot say whether this was a deliberate act by Israel or was, as they suggest, an operational accident. No body other those who committed the acts no the truth. And let me state this again I do not think it should have ever happened, whatever the truth. But when I talk of a more rounded, balanced view, I mean you should acknowledge similar things committed by both groups. Yet you just rant about one side,going as far as comparing their leader as Satan... So the killing of three aid workers is a tragedy we can both agree on. However when people me lion any facts which don't suit your narrative you seem to saying all lies and not the same. Soon in the interests of balance, are the murders of innocent contractors, supplying aid to the Middle East, justified a tragedy in the same way as these latest tragedies are? For context Muslim terrorist groups killed almost 800, yes 800 civilians who were supplying things such as food, water, electricity, infrastructure and medical supplies and services. This rose to over 1500 innocent civilians who were murdered by Muslim terrorist groups. This includes over 350 Americans and almost 60 Brits These weren't involved in military conflicts, crossfireetc. And I'm not saying that the three aid workers deaths were caused like this. I'm just saying g one said aid it was, one side said it wasn't. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with either explanation, ijust don't know. However it's harder to say the others didn't suffer murder atthe handsome one particular group, given that they were dragged out and shot, tortured, kept them captive and then killed. A significant number were beheaded, had their deaths posted on line. So if you are going to post something reference both sides, otherwise you a just a religious zealot and anti semite, Mrs x Another example if contratictory bull spouted out. this time in the same post So which bit is contradictory? Don't know why I bother asking, you never give answers just statement, Mrs x You accused me of virtue signalling, then quizz me if I'm an IRA sympathiser, then scoff me sbout what I did as a medic and told me what it was like and what I did when you weren't even fucking there!? " Hang on. I asked if you felt the same way in almost identical circumstances about terrorism and whether you felt the same in both circumstances, involving Hamas, who you appear to support and the IRA. As usual you haven't answered. I never scoffed your service in Bosnia, in fact I said it was laudable. I did point out though that when you said you protected Muslims in that conflict, thatchers were 25 Muslim leaders that were tried for war crimes. I mentioned this because of your vehement statement that you couldn't support war crimes and in particular those you believe were committed by Israel and the IDF. You seem very proud of your armed support for 'ACTUAL' Muslim war criminals though. You say that I said all this despite not being there. But you say loads about Israel and Gaza and I'm fairly certain you are not there. Irony really is lost on you. I don't have to be there to point out facts. Try it, it helps with your arguments. Mrs c | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Not sure whether you can't read or if you are just stupid. Think it must be stupid.... I've never said I wanted anyone killed. I've said all innocent lives lost on both sides is a terrible tragedy. The language you use and your arguments are infantile at best. You call Jews Zionists, when in reality most Jews living in Israel today or secular,non observant individuals. But you continue ue with Zionist because of the negative co notations you try to utilise to back up your ridiculous claims. Not sure if you've read any history but comparing a tone to Hitler is a stupid statement. It's how's how biased you are. Hitler killed millions of Jews. Not just Ziinistd like you want to claim but ordinary, moderate Jews, secular Jews, men, woman and children. Only other dictators are comparable, such as Stalin, Mao and the like. I ask you to provide a balanced, more rounded view, it makes it more interesting for the reader. For example, the latest tragedy involving the killing of aid workers is just that, an absolute tragedy and I feel so much sympathy for their families and love ones for their terrible loss. I cannot say whether this was a deliberate act by Israel or was, as they suggest, an operational accident. No body other those who committed the acts no the truth. And let me state this again I do not think it should have ever happened, whatever the truth. But when I talk of a more rounded, balanced view, I mean you should acknowledge similar things committed by both groups. Yet you just rant about one side,going as far as comparing their leader as Satan... So the killing of three aid workers is a tragedy we can both agree on. However when people me lion any facts which don't suit your narrative you seem to saying all lies and not the same. Soon in the interests of balance, are the murders of innocent contractors, supplying aid to the Middle East, justified a tragedy in the same way as these latest tragedies are? For context Muslim terrorist groups killed almost 800, yes 800 civilians who were supplying things such as food, water, electricity, infrastructure and medical supplies and services. This rose to over 1500 innocent civilians who were murdered by Muslim terrorist groups. This includes over 350 Americans and almost 60 Brits These weren't involved in military conflicts, crossfireetc. And I'm not saying that the three aid workers deaths were caused like this. I'm just saying g one said aid it was, one side said it wasn't. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with either explanation, ijust don't know. However it's harder to say the others didn't suffer murder atthe handsome one particular group, given that they were dragged out and shot, tortured, kept them captive and then killed. A significant number were beheaded, had their deaths posted on line. So if you are going to post something reference both sides, otherwise you a just a religious zealot and anti semite, Mrs x Another example if contratictory bull spouted out. this time in the same post " What's actually contradictory in anything I've said? Don't know why I bother asking, you never answer with facts just biased opinion, Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"Not sure whether you can't read or if you are just stupid. Think it must be stupid.... I've never said I wanted anyone killed. I've said all innocent lives lost on both sides is a terrible tragedy. The language you use and your arguments are infantile at best. You call Jews Zionists, when in reality most Jews living in Israel today or secular,non observant individuals. But you continue ue with Zionist because of the negative co notations you try to utilise to back up your ridiculous claims. Not sure if you've read any history but comparing a tone to Hitler is a stupid statement. It's how's how biased you are. Hitler killed millions of Jews. Not just Ziinistd like you want to claim but ordinary, moderate Jews, secular Jews, men, woman and children. Only other dictators are comparable, such as Stalin, Mao and the like. I ask you to provide a balanced, more rounded view, it makes it more interesting for the reader. For example, the latest tragedy involving the killing of aid workers is just that, an absolute tragedy and I feel so much sympathy for their families and love ones for their terrible loss. I cannot say whether this was a deliberate act by Israel or was, as they suggest, an operational accident. No body other those who committed the acts no the truth. And let me state this again I do not think it should have ever happened, whatever the truth. But when I talk of a more rounded, balanced view, I mean you should acknowledge similar things committed by both groups. Yet you just rant about one side,going as far as comparing their leader as Satan... So the killing of three aid workers is a tragedy we can both agree on. However when people me lion any facts which don't suit your narrative you seem to saying all lies and not the same. Soon in the interests of balance, are the murders of innocent contractors, supplying aid to the Middle East, justified a tragedy in the same way as these latest tragedies are? For context Muslim terrorist groups killed almost 800, yes 800 civilians who were supplying things such as food, water, electricity, infrastructure and medical supplies and services. This rose to over 1500 innocent civilians who were murdered by Muslim terrorist groups. This includes over 350 Americans and almost 60 Brits These weren't involved in military conflicts, crossfireetc. And I'm not saying that the three aid workers deaths were caused like this. I'm just saying g one said aid it was, one side said it wasn't. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with either explanation, ijust don't know. However it's harder to say the others didn't suffer murder atthe handsome one particular group, given that they were dragged out and shot, tortured, kept them captive and then killed. A significant number were beheaded, had their deaths posted on line. So if you are going to post something reference both sides, otherwise you a just a religious zealot and anti semite, Mrs x Another example if contratictory bull spouted out. this time in the same post So which bit is contradictory? Don't know why I bother asking, you never give answers just statement, Mrs x You accused me of virtue signalling, then quizz me if I'm an IRA sympathiser, then scoff me sbout what I did as a medic and told me what it was like and what I did when you weren't even fucking there!? Hang on. I asked if you felt the same way in almost identical circumstances about terrorism and whether you felt the same in both circumstances, involving Hamas, who you appear to support and the IRA. As usual you haven't answered. I never scoffed your service in Bosnia, in fact I said it was laudable. I did point out though that when you said you protected Muslims in that conflict, thatchers were 25 Muslim leaders that were tried for war crimes. I mentioned this because of your vehement statement that you couldn't support war crimes and in particular those you believe were committed by Israel and the IDF. You seem very proud of your armed support for 'ACTUAL' Muslim war criminals though. You say that I said all this despite not being there. But you say loads about Israel and Gaza and I'm fairly certain you are not there. Irony really is lost on you. I don't have to be there to point out facts. Try it, it helps with your arguments. Mrs c" That IRA shite again. Totally different situations. The IRA was a ludicrous needless movement that would never win, especially when political dialogue was the better option. The army never flattened huge areas, starved or shut off water supplies etc.. Politics with Isreal FAILED. because of far right racists. Lookup yitsak Rabin and Yasser Arafat.. those two came close but a far right nutjob assassinated Rabin, and now netanyahu took over, another far right nutjob who said nothing about the murder of Rabin. There's double standards with international law. It's okay for Isreal to attack the Iranian consulate, and would have known that Iran would respond. Isreal has provoke Iran for years. No-one including the pm Sunak, condemned that attack but they condemn the orchestrated Iran attack that Iran announced in advance so the drones could be shot down. Isreal is provoking a regional war and the USA and UK are party to it. Despite the failings and unexpected consequences of many failed wars. Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, .. International law is only followed by the West when it suits them. Isreal has broken countless UN rulings and is under investigation for war crimes. So another fucking stupid war looms while Isreal stirs up the flames of war Oh and btw., Check your posts regarding scoffing me. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x " I can point to the fact that attacking an embassy/ consulate is specifically against the Geneva convention as it is specifically designated as sovereign territory… is that good enough for you? So … Isreal started this particular episode… Iran responded by sending drones ( actually most of the aimed at a particular airbase in Israel where the type of planes used in the embassy attack were based) Back channels used.. for example Iran notified turkey, who then notified everyone else!… why do you think there was airspace closed and so many planes in place to intercept Now Isreal response is to again attack Iran…. Again attacking airbases… they let the US know….but it looks like no one else Isreal are banking on everyone else coming in and saving them! Because the US have already said they did it without support and the US did not back the decision…. Let’s see what happens when Iran give no notice…. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
| |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x " Your using opinion! In your opinion Isreal has done nothing wrong. Just about everyone else with a moderate balanced view disagree with you. Isreal has defied lots of UN mandates and resolutions and actions defined as illegal which as enflamed tensions in the region... Facts that are easily found on the internet. | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x Your using opinion! In your opinion Isreal has done nothing wrong. Just about everyone else with a moderate balanced view disagree with you. Isreal has defied lots of UN mandates and resolutions and actions defined as illegal which as enflamed tensions in the region... Facts that are easily found on the internet." You are making me laugh now. It's ridiculous Mrs x | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x Your using opinion! In your opinion Isreal has done nothing wrong. Just about everyone else with a moderate balanced view disagree with you. Isreal has defied lots of UN mandates and resolutions and actions defined as illegal which as enflamed tensions in the region... Facts that are easily found on the internet.You are making me laugh now. It's ridiculous Mrs x" Oh dear, your out of options now. How about answering the other post from Fabio? Attacking a consulate being illegal? | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x Your using opinion! In your opinion Isreal has done nothing wrong. Just about everyone else with a moderate balanced view disagree with you. Isreal has defied lots of UN mandates and resolutions and actions defined as illegal which as enflamed tensions in the region... Facts that are easily found on the internet.You are making me laugh now. It's ridiculous Mrs x" Looks like you lost .. again | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x Your using opinion! In your opinion Isreal has done nothing wrong. Just about everyone else with a moderate balanced view disagree with you. Isreal has defied lots of UN mandates and resolutions and actions defined as illegal which as enflamed tensions in the region... Facts that are easily found on the internet.You are making me laugh now. It's ridiculous Mrs x Looks like you lost .. again" And again ... | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
"You've not given any substantive facts. The Irish may dispute your claim about the British not destroying whole communities, King Billy, Black & Tans and Oliver Cromwell spring to mind. You talk of International Law but cannot actually point to one that has been proven to have been broken. You talk in generalities and opinions but none of that can be proven without facts. Which you never supply and will no doubt not again. Mrs x Your using opinion! In your opinion Isreal has done nothing wrong. Just about everyone else with a moderate balanced view disagree with you. Isreal has defied lots of UN mandates and resolutions and actions defined as illegal which as enflamed tensions in the region... Facts that are easily found on the internet.You are making me laugh now. It's ridiculous Mrs x Looks like you lost .. again And again ..." And again by denying facts! | |||
Reply privately (closed, thread got too big) | |||
